
tsdk
- January 28th, 2005
I have no Part II...just so you know....
December/January 2005
*Initials have been changed to protect dater identity
Is there really a difference between dating and friendship? Should there be? Is it crazy for their not to be? These are all questions I ask myself recently as I found myself in the beginning of a relationship with my “friend”.
When I think of the possible future, what most people define as natural steps in life they think about, a house, kids (maybe!) and/or pets, and someone to share it with. I always think that if I am going to go down that road, I hope to do it with my best friend. I try to envision a life with the “perfect” mate. If I had to define it, that means he doesn’t have to be perfect to anyone else, just perfect for me. I pictured the person who “gets” me and all my quirks, the one who accepts me for me and even likes all the weird stuff that makes me who I am. He didn’t have a name or a face, but I knew what kind of man I wanted him to be. I had all these requirements, kind of a checklist, that I thought I needed, but I was willing to bend more as time went on.
Having dated a ton over the past five years I almost started to feel like meeting someone compatible was just not in the cards for me. I didn’t want to think that because I am just more of a positive and optimistic person. I also would never close my mind to the possibility of finding that “other-half” because I am a romantic at heart. As time was moving forward though, I started to think that I didn’t even know how to be myself anymore and be the real me on a date with someone I liked, or even someone I didn’t like. Fear, hurt, and anxiety made me act like bitch on a bad day and Sybil on a good one. I put so much energy into trying to test people with my quirky behaviors, that eventually I didn’t know whether I was testing them or ME. They almost had no choice but to run the other way because I pushed them there. The bottom line was more that I didn’t want to let anyone in because every time I did, it ended badly for me. When you are constantly in fear of being bailed on, it is easy to keep romantic relationships at arm’s length even when you think you are ready for "The One".
After meeting some new girlfriends and taking on a new job in NYC, I decided to quit online dating. It wasn’t going anywhere for me. I had met someone I liked a lot in November on Jdate and thought it could go somewhere. I thought so until I realized that he thought online dating was a buffet and I was just some crudité in the corner of a packed plate. He was addicted like a crack-head. I had been there and seen that and wasn’t about to hang in for more of the same. Then, my friend told me about a guy she was really starting to like and told me his name. Before I could think about it, I mentioned that I knew him from online but never met him. She didn’t know he was dating from online and once I said that she had to wonder how real he was being. The crushed look on her face was enough for me to think that maybe online dating is really evil and that I needed a real break.
As much as I wanted to quit in my head, I still couldn’t totally stop. I stopped paying, but I didn’t take my profile down. I still had a few weeks left that were already paid for and I thought I could wean myself off slowly. I had never been totally off it though and I was scared.
I was having a party with my networking group in NJ and invited J*, a guy who I had emailed with sporadically with over the past year or so. I saw he was coming so I thought it would be cool to finally meet. I had no intention of dating him. I even tried to hook him up with my friends. On paper, he was not the person I envisioned myself with. He had contacted me on Jdate almost a year before and I was not interested. I even told him that. He is divorced, rides a Harley, likes dogs, and I would never again be able to wear shoes with a heel. Yes, all superficials for the most part, I admit, but everyone has their ideal. I figured I could always use another friend though, and I was curious about him for some reason.
When I did meet him, he said he had been off Jdate for approximately six months. I was still weaning myself off it. I couldn’t put my finger on it, but there was something there. At first I thought it was just friendship. We were talking every other day, then every day for hours at a time, and hanging out every few days. We kept saying it was great to have a “buddy”, yet we were simulating a junior high school courtship complete with long drives to nowhere, diner runs, and the phone surgically attached to our heads five times a day, talking about the deep and nonsensical, totally "getting" each other. It was starting to get to a “do or die” point because frankly, neither of us could keep up the amount of time we were devoting to the phone calls and even the hanging out. The bigger issue too was that we were already acting like we were dating, enjoying each other’s company, and being able to talk about anything. We just hadn’t crossed that line in labels or kissing. I did however finally take myself off Jdate around this time and didn’t have any hesitation. I didn’t need it as a crutch anymore.
Labels and kissing don’t seem like big deals, but crossing that line IS a big thing. I know because we did cross it, and the whole dynamic became different. Before, I didn’t think about whether I should call; I just did. I didn’t think about any shoulds or shouldn’ts. I just knew we liked spending time together and there was more sexual tension than any 80’s sitcom like Who’s the Boss? or dramedy like Moonlighting. Once we changed the rules or made some there was more deliberation in both our actions.
The line was crossed on the night he started the difficult conversation about where we see this friendship going. He made me talk when I really didn’t know how to express myself. I was afraid to have this conversation because I knew in the end of it we were going to have to make some kind of decision. He said we really might as well go for it because we had no reason not to. Then he was back and forth about it. I asked him if he wanted some time to think about it and he said no. We decided over the phone that we are dating. We did this before we even had one liplock. This seemed fitting, as our whole courtship was extremely reminiscent of being 15 yrs old and dating for the first time.
We had a weekend of “us” planned. Our first “date” was amazing. It was romantic and sweet and included that all-telling first kiss at the end of dinner. I was really happy. He seemed happy. I think things changed the next day. We had planned to go to the movies. I was feeling oddly irritable. I thought that maybe I was feeling that way because I was scared of what could or would or not happen. I was trying so hard not to overanalyze that it was coming out as bitchy attitude. As “just friends”, I felt comfortable being me because there isn’t that much at stake. As my “boyfriend” he would be playing a whole other role. If we messed this up as a romantic venture, we would lose our friendship too. I couldn’t help but feel the pressure because it had been so long since I was able to connect with someone that well and have so much fun. I managed to put bitchy aside that night and we went back to his place. I stayed there but we didn’t go beyond kissing. I don’t know what he wanted to do, but I know I was too scared to do anything. I wanted him but I didn’t know what would happen after that. Something felt off in the emotional connection and my head was telling me to stop even though my body wanted to continue. In my mind, the more sexual our relationship became, the more entrenched in a relationship we would be. I just felt like without sex we could somehow go back to being friends if it didn’t work out, but once we went to the point of intercourse it would forever change everything. Someone had to have the willpower and I just took that role myself.
We got into a serious conversation about what he wants in terms of his life regardless of whom he is dating. It seemed like he was trying to pick a fight or make me reconsider any idea of a future together. The things he was saying he wants were things he knew were not priorities to me. In my mind, he was basically telling me to “take it or leave it”. I left him that day wondering if we made the biggest mistake ever. I just wanted everything to go back to the way it was before. Unfortunately, that just wasn’t realistic.
Something wasn't right all week. He seemed distant and told me he made plans for the upcoming weekend, possibly both Friday and Saturday nights. I thought that was kind of strange since he had wanted to spend so much time together prior to labeling the relationship. I felt like he did that to make a statement. Finally, we started to talk and really flesh out was going on with him. He basically said that he was freaked out. The more he explained, the clearer to me it was that he was caught up in some idea of how things “should be” or “should feel” and overanalyzing the situation way beyond the necessary. I felt like this was the second “State of the Relationship Address” we had in seven days. It was a bit much even for me. We ended the conversation on a good note, so I thought. As I understood it, he just needed some time to get used to the idea of being in a relationship and we needed to take things slow. I didn’t really get it because he had been so gung-ho all this time. He had pursued me hard almost from the beginning. I wasn’t about to question it though because I wasn’t really sure what to think and I needed time to process everything. I also figured if he needed breathing room, I was just going to go with it.
Things just went from bad to worse into the weekend. I could feel him pulling away and I didn’t know what to do with that myself. There was an argument over the plan of the weekend and all just went to hell in a hand basket. I was hurt, angry & confused and I couldn’t figure out which I felt the most. I was angry with myself for letting him in and angry with him for taking advantage of that. Normally I would have written one of my famous long letters but he had taught me to speak instead of hide behind my writing. We emailed instead of spoke due to certain circumstances. He freaked and basically bailed on dating. I said we should go back to being friends because I liked it better that way. I didn’t even know if I meant it or what “friends” actually meant seeing as our whole relationship thus far was romance disguised as friendship. But, I had to put up some kind of wall as protection for my heart, so, that was my response. I also wasn’t sure if I was ready to lose our relationship on every level at that point.
He said he was glad to get my email and would love to be just friends again. He said he would call the next day.
Epilogue: We still have not spoken. I don’t know what is going to happen.
I wrote this in parts as it was happening. In a way, it was kind of like a “Choose your own adventure” kind of thing. In the beginning, my initial question was “What is the difference in dating your friend vs. someone new where there is nothing invested?”. Is it better or worse than starting fresh with a stranger? At first, I was so ready to write about how great it is to date someone you are already so close with. At this point I am not sure and somehow I don’t think I am going to know for quite some time. This doesn’t feel like the end of the tale.
When you date a stranger, you have nothing to lose. Even if you like this person and they turn out to be a jerk, or not that into you, you get over it relatively quickly. You have nothing established and there is no trust to break. When you date your friend, you have everything to gain if it works out, but everything to lose if it doesn’t. For the first five or six weeks where J. and I were just friends, I don’t think I have ever been happier. But, I am also not sure we were EVER “just friends”. I never had a J. He had become one of the closest people to me no matter how hard I tried to push him away with my quirks. He was someone I relied on to be there. I hadn’t had someone pay that much attention to me since I was a 14 yr old with my first real boyfriend. We laughed at everything and nothing, even things other people would definitely find offensive. We both cried at movies when we weren’t reciting the lines before they happened. He let me have excessive butter on our popcorn to the point of nausea. I used 4000 minutes on my cellular phone talking to him and judging by his phone bill, we should be on a share plan. He remembered everything I ever said and did. He knew he liked my hair one way over another and never noticed when I was disheveled. He could tell what I was doing in my apartment just by the sound of my voice or the background noise in the room. Sometimes when we looked at each other long enough, it was like seeing everything that was on the inside and not needing words.
I thought that taking it to the next level could only mean good things. In my mind, if I was ever to be in another relationship, I wanted to be able to call him my best friend. For a short while, J. seemed like he could be that person. I would want love to be based on the same core I found with J. Yet, as soon as a “relationship” label was put upon us, it ruined everything. This was the most intense short-lived relationship I ever had. It could possibly be a record.
I never believed in soul mates before. I am still not sure if I do. If I do, I am not sure what the definition of one should be. Maybe a soul mate doesn’t have to be a romantic partner, maybe it is just someone who “gets” you and it is just up to two people to figure out how to best fit that person into their life. J walked into my life and shook things up. He made me consider really letting someone see all my light AND love my dark. I never met someone who was so much on the same page most of the time to the point that it scared the hell out of me. But, scared never felt so right or gave me a mega-watt smile around the clock. I felt like if I had to define what I wanted out of a “relationship”, I had already found it right here. What else would I seek out? More superficial items from my old checklist? Checklists and rules just seemed so unimportant as J. and I got closer and the journey got better. You realize that this person is the first one you want to talk to for good and bad. When they become the first person you think of when your alarm goes off and the last person you think of before your eyes fall heavy with sleep, it’s like being alert and clear headed for the first time.
Then sometimes someone falls behind. There is a crossroads. You wonder if the other person can catch up or if they even want to continue on that path. Do you wait? If you wait are you wasting time or is waiting for your partner to catch up just part of love? Is falling behind sometimes just a natural part of actually keeping things together for the long haul? You begin to wonder if you imagined this connection that seemed so strong, so important, so solid. Where do you draw the line into knowing what relationships are worth fighting for? At this juncture it stops being fun and it becomes work. Do I want more work? Does every relationship have struggle and it is all about how you deal with it? What happens when the only obstacle to a really good relationship is the other person's fears?
The questions keep coming like a tidal wave. Should we look for our platonic friends to be our soul mates, or if you realize your friend is your soul mate do you have an obligation to see if it can work as more than a friendship? Some friendships might surpass most relationships but aren’t those usually same-sex friendships? Aren’t we ultimately looking for someone who is the most compatible for that “Great Love”? I think many people spend their whole life looking for the person to walk through life with that best enhances it. If you think you found that, isn’t it worth it to see it through for what it could be? Maybe you have to see where it can go because that is the natural progression in hetero relationships. Or, is it better not to risk the longevity of a really good platonic friendship? Would that just be stupid to not take the risk to reap the rewards? I think you would always wonder otherwise. Lastly, don’t all opposite-sex hetero friendships start out with some kind of attraction, conscious or subconscious and end up with some kind of romantic/sexual overture? Finally, what happens AFTER you give in to carnal urges? Your vulnerability gets wrapped up in the power of another person. Things are so easily misconstrued after you get naked. That is one insecure place to be.
I think relationships are difficult no matter what the label is on them. I don’t know the best way to start dating someone. The older I get and the MORE I date, the LESS I seem to know. If I had known the “dating” part of J & I was only going to last NINE DAYS and then be ruined, I would have never crossed that line. But, we also couldn’t sustain the level of what we were doing, whatever it was, because it was making us both lose sight of what we had on our life plates outside one another. It was mentally exhausting and exhilarating at the same time. Can two people who cross that line from friendship to more ever really go back to being friends if the relationship thing doesn’t work out? Can you only do that if you HAVEN'T had sex? Should you? When it ends, someone inevitably has gotten hurt. Usually one person makes a unilateral decision to flee. Feelings also can’t be turned on and off with a wave of a magic wand. Where does that leave the friendship on either side?
I totally let J in as my friend and by doing that, I gave him all the tools to hurt me in a relationship. Friends know best your strengths and weaknesses. They may not mean to use your weaknesses against you, but I think it is more subconscious. When someone feels the need to bail, they aren't looking at you as a "friend" anymore anyway. They also hold a trust card that is deeper and more fragile. When that trust is broken I don’t know if the foundation is repairable. On the other hand, a stranger is just a stranger. They start out meaning nothing outside of a physical attraction. New people in your life are often transient and are just blips on your radar. It takes time and energy to get to know someone and then actually form a true connection. By 30, we all have our own unique baggage and finding someone that loves you for it rather than in spite of it (and vice versa) isn’t easy. Your friend is already there loving you unconditionally (if you have good friends!) You may have nothing to lose with a stranger but is the gain as sweet as it could be with someone you already established trust and shared history?
The hardest questions of all are the ones I asked myself under the surface when I started to write. I know now that I am not ready to give up on finding love. I know what it is to feel giddy with happiness over having someone I think is super special in my life. I know that I like feeling and knowing I am special to someone else. I am just having trouble finding answers I need to figure out where to go with this relationship. My first instinct is to let it go and start fresh with someone new. But, how do I start over or even consider starting over with a stranger when all the components of something special and great are right there with my best friend? And if I let a new stranger in, won’t that new relationship have to replace the one with J? Am I ready and willing to totally give up J. to move on? Is he? Which is the bigger mistake, letting go what might be the best opposite sex friendship and relationship either one of us ever had or trying to save it and risking hurting each other beyond mend?
Maybe you just have to lose someone to appreciate what you had in the first place. If they realize it fast enough before there too much time and pain gone by, maybe part of being committed to being a best friend and/or more is helping the other person catch up when they stumble and fall behind. If they let you go, then maybe “perfect” was all just a figment of your imagination.